protobuf

19454 Commits

204 Branches

352 Tags

257 MiB

Tag: Branch: Tree: 8a17c53a5c

Commit Graph

Author	SHA1	Message	Date
Joshua Haberman	eab1fa2765	Fixed layering check violations once and for all in upb bootstrapping. Our bootstrapping setup compiles multiple versions of the generated code for `descriptor.proto` and `plugin.proto`, one for each stage of the bootstrap. For source files (`.c`), we can always select the correct version of the file in the BUILD rules, but for header files we need to make sure the correct stage's file is always selected via `#include`. Previously we used `cc_library(includes=[])` to make it appear as though our bootstrapped headers had the same names as the "real" headers. This allowed a lot of the code to be agnostic to whether a bootstrap header was being used, which simplified things because we did not have to change the code performing the `#include`. Unfortunately, due to build system limitations, this sometimes led to the incorrect header getting included. This should not have been possible, because we had a clean BUILD graph that should have removed all ambiguity about which header should be available. But in non-sandboxed builds, the compiler was able to find headers that were not actually in `deps=[]`, and worse it preferred those headers over the headers that actually were in `deps=[]`. This led to unintended results and errors about layering check violations. This CL fixes the problem by removing all use of `includes=[]`. We now spell a full pathname to all bootstrap headers, so this class of errors is no longer possible. Unfortunately this adds some complexity, as we have to hard-code these full paths in several places. A nice improvement in this CL is that `bootstrap_upb_proto_library()` can now only be used for bootstrapping; it only exposes the `descriptor_bootstrap.h` / `plugin_bootstrap.h` files. Anyone wanting to use the normal `net/proto2/proto/descriptor.upb.h` file should depend on `//net/proto2/proto:descriptor_upb_c_proto` target instead. PiperOrigin-RevId: 664953196	4 months ago

Author

SHA1

Message

Date

Joshua Haberman

eab1fa2765

Fixed layering check violations once and for all in upb bootstrapping.

Our bootstrapping setup compiles multiple versions of the generated code for `descriptor.proto` and `plugin.proto`, one for each stage of the bootstrap. For source files (`.c`), we can always select the correct version of the file in the BUILD rules, but for header files we need to make sure the correct stage's file is always selected via `#include`.

Previously we used `cc_library(includes=[])` to make it appear as though our bootstrapped headers had the same names as the "real" headers. This allowed a lot of the code to be agnostic to whether a bootstrap header was being used, which simplified things because we did not have to change the code performing the `#include`.

Unfortunately, due to build system limitations, this sometimes led to the incorrect header getting included. This should not have been possible, because we had a clean BUILD graph that should have removed all ambiguity about which header should be available. But in non-sandboxed builds, the compiler was able to find headers that were not actually in `deps=[]`, and worse it preferred those headers over the headers that actually were in `deps=[]`. This led to unintended results and errors about layering check violations.

This CL fixes the problem by removing all use of `includes=[]`. We now spell a full pathname to all bootstrap headers, so this class of errors is no longer possible. Unfortunately this adds some complexity, as we have to hard-code these full paths in several places.

A nice improvement in this CL is that `bootstrap_upb_proto_library()` can now only be used for bootstrapping; it only exposes the `descriptor_bootstrap.h` / `plugin_bootstrap.h` files. Anyone wanting to use the normal `net/proto2/proto/descriptor.upb.h` file should depend on `//net/proto2/proto:descriptor_upb_c_proto` target instead.

PiperOrigin-RevId: 664953196

4 months ago

1 Commits (8a17c53a5cfa3502d2dcededc75ed840e71d6540)