Tag:
Branch:
Tree:
1c28a98b34
2.4
3.4
4.x
5.x
master
next
2.2
2.3.0
2.3.1
2.4.0
2.4.1
2.4.10
2.4.10.1
2.4.10.2
2.4.10.3
2.4.10.4
2.4.11
2.4.12
2.4.12.1
2.4.12.2
2.4.12.3
2.4.13
2.4.13.1
2.4.13.2
2.4.13.3
2.4.13.4
2.4.13.5
2.4.13.6
2.4.13.7
2.4.2
2.4.3
2.4.3-rc
2.4.3.1
2.4.3.2
2.4.4
2.4.4-beta
2.4.5
2.4.6
2.4.6.1
2.4.6.2
2.4.6.2-rc1
2.4.6.2r2
2.4.6.2r3
2.4.7
2.4.7-rc1
2.4.7.1
2.4.7.2
2.4.8
2.4.8.1
2.4.8.2
2.4.8.3
2.4.9
2.4.9.1
3.0-ocl-tech-preview
3.0-ocl-tp2
3.0.0
3.0.0-alpha
3.0.0-beta
3.0.0-rc1
3.1.0
3.2.0
3.2.0-rc
3.3.0
3.3.0-cvsdk
3.3.0-rc
3.3.1
3.3.1-cvsdk
3.4.0
3.4.0-rc
3.4.1
3.4.1-cvsdk
3.4.10
3.4.11
3.4.12
3.4.13
3.4.14
3.4.15
3.4.16
3.4.17
3.4.18
3.4.19
3.4.2
3.4.2-openvino
3.4.20
3.4.3
3.4.3-openvino
3.4.4
3.4.5
3.4.6
3.4.7
3.4.8
3.4.9
4.0.0
4.0.0-alpha
4.0.0-beta
4.0.0-openvino
4.0.0-rc
4.0.1
4.0.1-openvino
4.1.0
4.1.0-openvino
4.1.1
4.1.1-openvino
4.1.2
4.1.2-openvino
4.10.0
4.10.0-kleidicv
4.11.0
4.2.0
4.2.0-openvino
4.3.0
4.3.0-openvino
4.3.0-openvino-2020.3.0
4.4.0
4.4.0-openvino
4.5.0
4.5.0-openvino
4.5.1
4.5.1-openvino
4.5.2
4.5.2-openvino
4.5.3
4.5.3-openvino
4.5.3-openvino-2021.4.1
4.5.3-openvino-2021.4.2
4.5.4
4.5.5
4.5.5-openvino-2022.1.0
4.6.0
4.7.0
4.8.0
4.8.1
4.9.0
5.0.0-alpha
${ noResults }
1 Commits (1c28a98b3484e37e75012e555c2db8f9e98d7dc1)
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
Pierre Chatelier
|
60b806f9b8
|
Merge pull request #22947 from chacha21:hasNonZero
Added cv::hasNonZero() #22947 `cv::hasNonZero()` is semantically equivalent to (`cv::countNonZero()>0`) but stops parsing the image when a non-zero value is found, for a performance gain - [X] I agree to contribute to the project under Apache 2 License. - [X] To the best of my knowledge, the proposed patch is not based on a code under GPL or another license that is incompatible with OpenCV - [X] The PR is proposed to the proper branch - [ ] There is a reference to the original bug report and related work - [ ] There is accuracy test, performance test and test data in opencv_extra repository, if applicable Patch to opencv_extra has the same branch name. - [ ] The feature is well documented and sample code can be built with the project CMake This pull request might be refused, but I submit it to know if further work is needed or if I just stop working on it. The idea is only a performance gain vs `countNonZero()>0` at the cost of more code. Reasons why it might be refused : - this is just more code - the execution time is "unfair"/"unpredictable" since it depends on the position of the first non-zero value - the user must be aware that default search is from first row/col to last row/col and has no way to customize that, even if his use case lets him know where a non zero could be found - the PR in its current state is using, for the ocl implementation, a mere `countNonZero()>0` ; there is not much sense in trying to break early the ocl kernel call when non-zero is encountered. So the ocl implementation does not bring any improvement. - there is no IPP function that can help (`countNonZero()` is based in `ippCountInRange`) - the PR in its current state might be slower than a call to `countNonZero()>0` in some cases (see "challenges" below) Reasons why it might be accepted : - the performance gain is huge on average, if we consider that "on average" means "non zero in the middle of the image" - the "missing" IPP implementation is replaced by an "Open-CV universal intrinsics" implementation - the PR in its current state is almost always faster than a call to `countNonZero()>0`, is only slightly slower in the worst cases, and not even for all matrices **Challenges** The worst case is either an all-zero matrix, or a non-zero at the very last position. In such a case, the `hasNonZero()` implementation will parse the whole matrix like `countNonZero()` would do. But we expect the performance to be the same in this case. And `ippCountInRange` is hard to beat ! There is also the case of very small matrices (<=32x32...) in 8b, where the SIMD can be hard to feed. For all cases but the worse, my custom `hasNonZero()` performs better than `ippCountInRange()` For the worst case, my custom `hasNonZero()` performs better than `ippCountInRange()` *except for large matrices of type CV_32S or CV_64F* (but surprisingly, not CV_32F). The difference is small, but it exists (and I don't understand why). For very small CV_8U matrices `ippCountInRange()` seems unbeatable. Here is the code that I use to check timings ``` //test cv::hasNonZero() vs (cv::countNonZero()>0) for different matrices sizes, types, strides... { cv::setRNGSeed(1234); const std::vector<cv::Size> sizes = {{32, 32}, {64, 64}, {128, 128}, {320, 240}, {512, 512}, {640, 480}, {1024, 768}, {2048, 2048}, {1031, 1000}}; const std::vector<int> types = {CV_8U, CV_16U, CV_32S, CV_32F, CV_64F}; const size_t iterations = 1000; for(const cv::Size& size : sizes) { for(const int type : types) { for(int c = 0 ; c<2 ; ++c) { const bool continuous = !c; for(int i = 0 ; i<4 ; ++i) { cv::Mat m = continuous ? cv::Mat::zeros(size, type) : cv::Mat(cv::Mat::zeros(cv::Size(2*size.width, size.height), type), cv::Rect(cv::Point(0, 0), size)); const bool nz = (i <= 2); const unsigned int nzOffsetRange = 10; const unsigned int nzOffset = cv::randu<unsigned int>()%nzOffsetRange; const cv::Point pos = (i == 0) ? cv::Point(nzOffset, 0) : (i == 1) ? cv::Point(size.width/2-nzOffsetRange/2+nzOffset, size.height/2) : (i == 2) ? cv::Point(size.width-1-nzOffset, size.height-1) : cv::Point(0, 0); std::cout << "============================================================" << std::endl; std::cout << "size:" << size << " type:" << type << " continuous = " << (continuous ? "true" : "false") << " iterations:" << iterations << " nz=" << (nz ? "true" : "false"); std::cout << " pos=" << ((i == 0) ? "begin" : (i == 1) ? "middle" : (i == 2) ? "end" : "none"); std::cout << std::endl; cv::Mat mask = cv::Mat::zeros(size, CV_8UC1); mask.at<unsigned char>(pos) = 0xFF; m.setTo(cv::Scalar::all(0)); m.setTo(cv::Scalar::all(nz ? 1 : 0), mask); std::vector<bool> results; std::vector<double> timings; { bool res = false; auto ref = cv::getTickCount(); for(size_t k = 0 ; k<iterations ; ++k) res = cv::hasNonZero(m); auto now = cv::getTickCount(); const bool error = (res != nz); if (error) printf("!!ERROR!!\r\n"); results.push_back(res); timings.push_back(1000.*(now-ref)/cv::getTickFrequency()); } { bool res = false; auto ref = cv::getTickCount(); for(size_t k = 0 ; k<iterations ; ++k) res = (cv::countNonZero(m)>0); auto now = cv::getTickCount(); const bool error = (res != nz); if (error) printf("!!ERROR!!\r\n"); results.push_back(res); timings.push_back(1000.*(now-ref)/cv::getTickFrequency()); } const size_t bestTimingIndex = (std::min_element(timings.begin(), timings.end())-timings.begin()); if ((bestTimingIndex != 0) || (std::find_if_not(results.begin(), results.end(), [&](bool r) {return (r == nz);}) != results.end())) { std::cout << "cv::hasNonZero\t\t=>" << results[0] << ((results[0] != nz) ? " ERROR" : "") << " perf:" << timings[0] << "ms => " << (iterations/timings[0]*1000) << " im/s" << ((bestTimingIndex == 0) ? " * " : "") << std::endl; std::cout << "cv::countNonZero\t=>" << results[1] << ((results[1] != nz) ? " ERROR" : "") << " perf:" << timings[1] << "ms => " << (iterations/timings[1]*1000) << " im/s" << ((bestTimingIndex == 1) ? " * " : "") << std::endl; } } } } } } ``` Here is a report of this benchmark (it only reports timings when `cv::countNonZero()` is faster) My CPU is an Intel Core I7 4790 @ 3.60Ghz ``` ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle cv::hasNonZero =>1 perf:0.353764ms => 2.82674e+06 im/s cv::countNonZero =>1 perf:0.282044ms => 3.54555e+06 im/s * ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end cv::hasNonZero =>1 perf:0.610478ms => 1.63806e+06 im/s cv::countNonZero =>1 perf:0.283182ms => 3.5313e+06 im/s * ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none cv::hasNonZero =>0 perf:0.630115ms => 1.58701e+06 im/s cv::countNonZero =>0 perf:0.282044ms => 3.54555e+06 im/s * ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end cv::hasNonZero =>1 perf:0.607347ms => 1.64651e+06 im/s cv::countNonZero =>1 perf:0.467037ms => 2.14116e+06 im/s * ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none cv::hasNonZero =>0 perf:0.618162ms => 1.6177e+06 im/s cv::countNonZero =>0 perf:0.468175ms => 2.13595e+06 im/s * ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[32 x 32] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[64 x 64] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[128 x 128] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[320 x 240] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[512 x 512] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[640 x 480] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1024 x 768] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end cv::hasNonZero =>1 perf:895.381ms => 1116.84 im/s cv::countNonZero =>1 perf:882.569ms => 1133.06 im/s * ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none cv::hasNonZero =>0 perf:899.53ms => 1111.69 im/s cv::countNonZero =>0 perf:870.894ms => 1148.24 im/s * ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end cv::hasNonZero =>1 perf:2018.92ms => 495.313 im/s cv::countNonZero =>1 perf:1966.37ms => 508.552 im/s * ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none cv::hasNonZero =>0 perf:2005.87ms => 498.537 im/s cv::countNonZero =>0 perf:1992.78ms => 501.812 im/s * ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[2048 x 2048] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:0 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:2 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:4 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:5 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = true iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=begin ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=middle ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=true pos=end ============================================================ size:[1031 x 1000] type:6 continuous = false iterations:1000 nz=false pos=none done ``` |
2 years ago |