More changes as part of the dualstack design:
- Change resolver and LB policy APIs to support multiple addresses per
endpoint. Specifically, replace `ServerAddress` with
`EndpointAddresses`, which encodes more than one address. Per-address
channel args are retained at the same level, so they are now
per-endpoint. For now, `EndpointAddress` provides a single-address ctor
and a single-address accessor for backward compatibility, so
`ServerAdress` is an alias for `EndpointAddresses`; eventually, this
alias and the single-address methods will be removed.
- Add an `EndpointAddressSet` class, which represents an unordered set
of addresses to be used as a map key. This will be used in a number of
LB policies that need to store per-endpoint state.
- Change the LB policy API's `ChannelControlHelper::CreateSubchannel()`
method to take the address and per-endpoint channel args as separate
parameters, so that we don't need to construct a legacy `ServerAddress`
object as we create a new subchannel for each address in the endpoint.
- Change pick_first to flatten the address list.
- Change ring_hash to use `EndpointAddressSet` as the key for its
endpoint map, and to use the first address of the endpoint as the hash
key.
- Change WRR to use `EndpointAddressSet` as the key for its endpoint
weight map.
Note that support for multiple addresses per endpoint is guarded in RR
by the existing `round_robin_delegate_to_pick_fist` experiment and in
WRR by the existing `wrr_delegate_to_pick_first` experiment.
This PR does *not* include support for multiple addresses per endpoint
for the outlier_detection or xds_override_host LB policies; those will
come in subsequent PRs.
This test assumed synchronous work serializer execution (or at least
faster async than we always get)... make a trivial change to keep the
test semantics but allow for the implementation to be more async.
Most recent attempt was #34320, reverted in #34335.
The first commit here is a pure revert. The second commit fixes the
outlier_detection unit test to pass both with and without the
experiment.
Rolls forward part of the dualstack changes, mostly from #33427 and a
little bit from #32692, both of which were reverted in #33718.
Specifically:
- For petiole policies, unconditionally start health watch on
subchannels, even if client side health checking is not enabled; in this
case, the health watch will report the subchannel's raw connectivity
state.
- Fix edge cases in health check reporting that occur when a watcher is
started before the initial state is reported.
- When client-side health checking fails, add the subchannel's address
to the RPC failure status message.
- Outlier detection now works only via the health checking watch, not
via the raw connectivity state watch.
- Remove now-unnecessary hack to ensure that outlier detection does not
work for pick_first.
CNR the flake, but I've changed the test (which is very old) to use some
of our more modern helper functions that have saner timeouts.
Also re-add a `return` statement that was accidentally removed in
#33753, which I noticed while working on this. Its absence doesn't cause
a real problem, but it does cause us to needlessly trigger a duplicate
connection attempt or report a duplicate CONNECTING update in some
cases.
Fix sticky-TF behavior such that once we enter TRANSIENT_FAILURE, we do
not leave that state if we get a new address list.
Also, fix handling of subchannels in state TRANSIENT_FAILURE.
Previously, if a subchannel was already in state TRANSIENT_FAILURE when
we wanted to start a connection attempt on it (e.g., because the
subchannel already existed from a different channel, or because it
already existed in the previous subchannel list), we would wait for it
to report IDLE before attempting to connect. This PR changes pick_first
to instead immediately skip the subchannel and move on to the next one.
Now, the only time we wait for a subchannel in TRANSIENT_FAILURE is when
we wrap back around to the first subchannel in the list.
I'm fairly certain that this path should be non-blocking (and making it
so makes the promise based code far more tractable).
This moves the blocking behavior into the blocking server_cc.cc function
that calls `grpc_server_shutdown_and_notify` instead of in that
non-blocking function.
---------
Co-authored-by: ctiller <ctiller@users.noreply.github.com>
This reverts the following PRs: #32692#33087#33093#33427#33568
These changes seem to have introduced some flaky crashes. Reverting
while I investigate.
As per gRFC A58, when WRR sees a subchannel report READY, it reset the
non_empty_since value, thus restarting the blackout period. However,
there were two cases where we were incorrectly triggering this code:
1. When WRR got an updated address list that contained addresses that
were already present on the old list and whose subchannels were already
in READY state, the initial notification for those subchannels on the
new list was READY, which incorrectly triggered resetting the
non_empty_since value.
2. Due to a bug in the outlier_detection policy, whenever an update was
propagated down through the OD policy without actually enabling OD, it
would incorrectly send a duplicate connectivity state notification for
the subchannels. This meant that a subchannel that was already in state
READY would report READY again, which would also incorrectly trigger
resetting the non_empty_since value.
This PR makes two changes:
1. Fix the bug in outlier_detection that caused it to generate the
spurious duplicate READY updates.
2. Fix WRR to reset the non_empty_since value when a subchannel goes
READY only if the subchannel has seen a previous state update and only
if that previous state was not READY. (The duplicate READY notifications
should not actually happen anymore now that the OD policy has been
fixed, but better to be defensive.)
Fixes b/290983884.
More work on the dualstack backend design:
- Now that all petiole policies have been changed to delegate to
pick_first, outlier detection no longer needs to eject via the
subchannel's raw connectivity state; it can now eject only via the
health state. See #33340.
- This also removes the now-unnecessary hack to explicitly disable
outlier detection in pick_first. See #33336.
More work on the dualstack backend design:
- Change round_robin to delegate to pick_first instead of creating
subchannels directly.
- Change pick_first such that when it is the child of a petiole policy,
it will unconditionally start a health watch.
- Change the client-side health checking code such that if client-side
health checking is not enabled, it will return the subchannel's raw
connectivity state.
- As part of this, we introduce a new endpoint_list library to be used
by petiole policies, which is intended to replace the existing
subchannel_list library. The only policy that will still directly
interact with subchannels is pick_first, so the relevant parts of the
subchannel_list functionality have been copied directly into that
policy. The subchannel_list library will be removed after all petiole
policies are updated to delegate to pick_first.
The address attribute interface was intended to provide a mechanism to
pass attributes separately from channel args, for values that do not
affect subchannel behavior and therefore do not need to be present in
the subchannel key, which does include channel args. However, the
mechanism as currently designed is fairly clunky and is probably not the
direction we will want to go in the long term.
Eventually, we will want some mechanism for registering channel args,
which would provide a cleaner way to indicate that a given channel arg
should not be used in the subchannel key, so that we don't need a
completely different mechanism. For now, this PR is just doing an
interim step, which is to establish a special channel arg key prefix to
indicate that an arg is not needed in the subchannel key.
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
Reverts grpc/grpc#33002. Breaks internal builds:
`.../privacy_context:filters does not depend on a module exporting
'.../src/core/lib/channel/context.h'`
Change call attributes to be stored in a `ChunkedVector` instead of
`std::map<>`, so that the storage can be allocated on the arena. This
means that we're now doing a linear search instead of a map lookup, but
the total number of attributes is expected to be low enough that that
should be okay.
Also, we now hide the actual data structure inside of the
`ServiceConfigCallData` object, which required some changes to the
`ConfigSelector` API. Previously, the `ConfigSelector` would return a
`CallConfig` struct, and the client channel would then use the data in
that struct to populate the `ServiceConfigCallData`. This PR changes
that such that the client channel creates the `ServiceConfigCallData`
before invoking the `ConfigSelector`, and it passes the
`ServiceConfigCallData` into the `ConfigSelector` so that the
`ConfigSelector` can populate it directly.
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
---------
Co-authored-by: ctiller <ctiller@users.noreply.github.com>
This reverts commit 7bd9267f32.
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
This is a big rewrite of global config.
It does a few things, all somewhat intertwined:
1. centralize the list of configuration we have to a yaml file that can
be parsed, and code generated from it
2. add an initialization and a reset stage so that config vars can be
centrally accessed very quickly without the need for caching them
3. makes the syntax more C++ like (less macros!)
4. (optionally) adds absl flags to the OSS build
This first round of changes is intended to keep the system where it is
without major changes. We pick up absl flags to match internal code and
remove one point of deviation - but importantly continue to read from
the environment variables. In doing so we don't force absl flags on our
customers - it's possible to configure grpc without the flags - but
instead allow users that do use absl flags to configure grpc using that
mechanism. Importantly this lets internal customers configure grpc the
same everywhere.
Future changes along this path will be two-fold:
1. Move documentation generation into the code generation step, so that
within the source of truth yaml file we can find all documentation and
data about a configuration knob - eliminating the chance of forgetting
to document something in all the right places.
2. Provide fuzzing over configurations. Currently most config variables
get stashed in static constants across the codebase. To fuzz over these
we'd need a way to reset those cached values between fuzzing rounds,
something that is terrifically difficult right now, but with these
changes should simply be a reset on `ConfigVars`.
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
---------
Co-authored-by: ctiller <ctiller@users.noreply.github.com>
We currently take named metrics recorded per-request only. Instead we
should merge field-wise.
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
<!--
If you know who should review your pull request, please assign it to
that
person, otherwise the pull request would get assigned randomly.
If your pull request is for a specific language, please add the
appropriate
lang label.
-->
* Revert "Revert "Revert "Revert "server: introduce ServerMetricRecorder API and move per-call reporting from a C++ interceptor to a C-core filter (#32106)" (#32272)" (#32279)" (#32293)"
This reverts commit 1f960697c5.
* Do not create CallMetricRecorder if call is null.
* Revert "Revert "server: introduce ServerMetricRecorder API and move per-call reporting from a C++ interceptor to a C-core filter (#32106)" (#32272)"
This reverts commit deb1e25543.
* Fix by caching call metric recording stuff in async request
PR #32106 caused msan errors in some tests while de-referencing the
server object where async calls are active after the server is
destroyed. Instead cache the ServerMetricRecorder pointer.
* copyright headers fixed
* clang fixes.
* WRR: port StaticStrideScheduler to OSS
* WIP
* Automated change: Fix sanity tests
* fix build
* remove unused aliases
* fix another type mismatch
* remove unnecessary include
* move benchmarks to their own file, and don't run it on windows
* Automated change: Fix sanity tests
* add OOB reporting
* generate_projects
* clang-format
* add config parser test
* clang-tidy and minimize lock contention
* add config defaults
* add oob_reporting_period config field and add basic test
* Automated change: Fix sanity tests
* fix test
* change test to use basic RR
* WIP: started exposing peer address to LB policy API
* first WRR test passing!
* small cleanup
* port RR fix to WRR
* test helper refactoring
* more test helper refactoring
* WIP: trying to fix test to have the right weights
* more WIP -- need to make pickers DualRefCounted
* fix timer ref handling and get tests working
* clang-format
* iwyu and generate_projects
* fix build
* add test for OOB reporting
* keep only READY subchannels in the picker
* add file missed in a previous commit
* fix sanity
* iwyu
* add weight expiration period
* add tests for weight update period and OOB reporting period
* Automated change: Fix sanity tests
* lower bound for timer interval
* consistently apply grpc_test_slowdown_factor()
* cache time in test
* add blackout_period tests
* avoid some unnecessary copies
* clang-format
* add field to config test
* simplify orca watcher tracking
* attempt to fix build
* iwyu
* generate_projects
* add "_experimental" suffix to policy name
* WRR: update tests to cover qps plumbing
* WIP
* more WIP
* basic WRR e2e test working
* add OOB test
* fix sanity
* ignore duplicate addresses
* Automated change: Fix sanity tests
* add new tracer to doc/environment_variables.md
* retain scheduler state across pickers
* Automated change: Fix sanity tests
* use separate mutexes for scheduler and timer
* sort addresses to avoid index churn
* remove fetch_sub for wrap around in RR case
Co-authored-by: markdroth <markdroth@users.noreply.github.com>
Mark D. Roth
Vignesh Babu
Craig Tiller
Yousuk Seung
AJ Heller
Esun Kim
Jan Tattermusch
Yijie Ma
Xuan Wang