The C based gRPC (C++, Python, Ruby, Objective-C, PHP, C#) https://grpc.io/
You can not select more than 25 topics Topics must start with a letter or number, can include dashes ('-') and can be up to 35 characters long.

1551 lines
52 KiB

#!/usr/bin/env python
# Copyright 2015 gRPC authors.
#
# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
# you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
# You may obtain a copy of the License at
#
# http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
#
# Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
# distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
# limitations under the License.
"""Run interop (cross-language) tests in parallel."""
from __future__ import print_function
import argparse
import atexit
import itertools
import json
import multiprocessing
import os
import re
import subprocess
import sys
import tempfile
import time
import uuid
import six
import traceback
import python_utils.dockerjob as dockerjob
import python_utils.jobset as jobset
import python_utils.report_utils as report_utils
# It's ok to not import because this is only necessary to upload results to BQ.
try:
7 years ago
from python_utils.upload_test_results import upload_interop_results_to_bq
except ImportError as e:
7 years ago
print(e)
# Docker doesn't clean up after itself, so we do it on exit.
atexit.register(lambda: subprocess.call(['stty', 'echo']))
ROOT = os.path.abspath(os.path.join(os.path.dirname(sys.argv[0]), '../..'))
os.chdir(ROOT)
7 years ago
_DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT = 8080
7 years ago
_SKIP_CLIENT_COMPRESSION = [
'client_compressed_unary', 'client_compressed_streaming'
]
7 years ago
_SKIP_SERVER_COMPRESSION = [
'server_compressed_unary', 'server_compressed_streaming'
]
_SKIP_COMPRESSION = _SKIP_CLIENT_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_SERVER_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
_SKIP_ADVANCED = [
'status_code_and_message', 'custom_metadata', 'unimplemented_method',
'unimplemented_service'
]
_SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE = ['special_status_message']
7 years ago
_TEST_TIMEOUT = 3 * 60
# disable this test on core-based languages,
# see https://github.com/grpc/grpc/issues/9779
_SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING = ['data_frame_padding']
# report suffix "sponge_log.xml" is important for reports to get picked up by internal CI
_DOCKER_BUILD_XML_REPORT = 'interop_docker_build/sponge_log.xml'
_TESTS_XML_REPORT = 'interop_test/sponge_log.xml'
class CXXLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = None
self.server_cwd = None
self.http2_cwd = None
self.safename = 'cxx'
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['bins/opt/interop_client'] + args
7 years ago
def client_cmd_http2interop(self, args):
return ['bins/opt/http2_client'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['bins/opt/interop_server'] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return []
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'c++'
class CSharpLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = 'src/csharp/Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Client/bin/Debug/net45'
self.server_cwd = 'src/csharp/Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Server/bin/Debug/net45'
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['mono', 'Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Client.exe'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['mono', 'Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Server.exe'] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_SERVER_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'csharp'
class CSharpCoreCLRLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = 'src/csharp/Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Client/bin/Debug/netcoreapp1.1'
self.server_cwd = 'src/csharp/Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Server/bin/Debug/netcoreapp1.1'
7 years ago
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['dotnet', 'exec', 'Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Client.dll'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['dotnet', 'exec', 'Grpc.IntegrationTesting.Server.dll'] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_SERVER_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'csharpcoreclr'
class DartLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = '../grpc-dart/interop'
self.server_cwd = '../grpc-dart/interop'
self.http2_cwd = '../grpc-dart/interop'
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['dart', 'bin/client.dart'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['dart', 'bin/server.dart'] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'dart'
class JavaLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = '../grpc-java'
self.server_cwd = '../grpc-java'
self.http2_cwd = '../grpc-java'
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['./run-test-client.sh'] + args
7 years ago
def client_cmd_http2interop(self, args):
return [
'./interop-testing/build/install/grpc-interop-testing/bin/http2-client'
] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['./run-test-server.sh'] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return []
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'java'
class JavaOkHttpClient:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = '../grpc-java'
self.safename = 'java'
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['./run-test-client.sh', '--use_okhttp=true'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'javaokhttp'
class GoLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
# TODO: this relies on running inside docker
self.client_cwd = '/go/src/google.golang.org/grpc/interop/client'
self.server_cwd = '/go/src/google.golang.org/grpc/interop/server'
self.http2_cwd = '/go/src/google.golang.org/grpc/interop/http2'
self.safename = str(self)
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['go', 'run', 'client.go'] + args
7 years ago
def client_cmd_http2interop(self, args):
return ['go', 'run', 'negative_http2_client.go'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['go', 'run', 'server.go'] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'go'
class Http2Server:
7 years ago
"""Represents the HTTP/2 Interop Test server
This pretends to be a language in order to be built and run, but really it
isn't.
"""
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.server_cwd = None
self.safename = str(self)
def server_cmd(self, args):
return ['python test/http2_test/http2_test_server.py']
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _TEST_CASES + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _TEST_CASES
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'http2'
class Http2Client:
7 years ago
"""Represents the HTTP/2 Interop Test
This pretends to be a language in order to be built and run, but really it
isn't.
"""
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = None
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['tools/http2_interop/http2_interop.test', '-test.v'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _TEST_CASES + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _TEST_CASES
def __str__(self):
return 'http2'
class NodeLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = '../grpc-node'
self.server_cwd = '../grpc-node'
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return [
'packages/grpc-native-core/deps/grpc/tools/run_tests/interop/with_nvm.sh',
'node', '--require', './test/fixtures/native_native',
7 years ago
'test/interop/interop_client.js'
] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return [
'packages/grpc-native-core/deps/grpc/tools/run_tests/interop/with_nvm.sh',
'node', '--require', './test/fixtures/native_native',
7 years ago
'test/interop/interop_server.js'
] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'node'
class NodePureJSLanguage:
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = '../grpc-node'
self.server_cwd = '../grpc-node'
self.safename = str(self)
def client_cmd(self, args):
return [
'packages/grpc-native-core/deps/grpc/tools/run_tests/interop/with_nvm.sh',
'node', '--require', './test/fixtures/js_js',
'test/interop/interop_client.js'
] + args
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
def global_env(self):
return {}
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return []
def __str__(self):
return 'nodepurejs'
class PHPLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = None
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['src/php/bin/interop_client.sh'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return []
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'php'
class PHP7Language:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = None
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return ['src/php/bin/interop_client.sh'] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return []
def __str__(self):
return 'php7'
class ObjcLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = 'src/objective-c/tests'
self.safename = str(self)
def client_cmd(self, args):
# from args, extract the server port and craft xcodebuild command out of it
for arg in args:
port = re.search('--server_port=(\d+)', arg)
if port:
portnum = port.group(1)
cmdline = 'pod install && xcodebuild -workspace Tests.xcworkspace -scheme InteropTestsLocalSSL -destination name="iPhone 6" HOST_PORT_LOCALSSL=localhost:%s test' % portnum
return [cmdline]
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
# ObjC test runs all cases with the same command. It ignores the testcase
# cmdline argument. Here we return all but one test cases as unimplemented,
# and depend upon ObjC test's behavior that it runs all cases even when
# we tell it to run just one.
return _TEST_CASES[1:] + _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
7 years ago
def __str__(self):
return 'objc'
class RubyLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = None
self.server_cwd = None
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return [
'tools/run_tests/interop/with_rvm.sh', 'ruby',
'src/ruby/pb/test/client.rb'
] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return [
'tools/run_tests/interop/with_rvm.sh', 'ruby',
'src/ruby/pb/test/server.rb'
] + args
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_SERVER_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
def __str__(self):
return 'ruby'
class PythonLanguage:
7 years ago
def __init__(self):
self.client_cwd = None
self.server_cwd = None
self.http2_cwd = None
self.safename = str(self)
7 years ago
def client_cmd(self, args):
return [
'py37_native/bin/python', 'src/python/grpcio_tests/setup.py',
7 years ago
'run_interop', '--client', '--args="{}"'.format(' '.join(args))
]
def client_cmd_http2interop(self, args):
return [
'py37_native/bin/python',
7 years ago
'src/python/grpcio_tests/tests/http2/negative_http2_client.py',
] + args
7 years ago
def cloud_to_prod_env(self):
return {}
7 years ago
def server_cmd(self, args):
return [
'py37_native/bin/python', 'src/python/grpcio_tests/setup.py',
7 years ago
'run_interop', '--server', '--args="{}"'.format(' '.join(args))
]
7 years ago
def global_env(self):
return {
'LD_LIBRARY_PATH': '{}/libs/opt'.format(DOCKER_WORKDIR_ROOT),
'PYTHONPATH': '{}/src/python/gens'.format(DOCKER_WORKDIR_ROOT)
}
7 years ago
def unimplemented_test_cases(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_DATA_FRAME_PADDING
def unimplemented_test_cases_server(self):
return _SKIP_COMPRESSION
def __str__(self):
return 'python'
_LANGUAGES = {
7 years ago
'c++': CXXLanguage(),
'csharp': CSharpLanguage(),
'csharpcoreclr': CSharpCoreCLRLanguage(),
'dart': DartLanguage(),
7 years ago
'go': GoLanguage(),
'java': JavaLanguage(),
'javaokhttp': JavaOkHttpClient(),
'node': NodeLanguage(),
'nodepurejs': NodePureJSLanguage(),
7 years ago
'php': PHPLanguage(),
'php7': PHP7Language(),
'objc': ObjcLanguage(),
'ruby': RubyLanguage(),
'python': PythonLanguage(),
}
# languages supported as cloud_to_cloud servers
7 years ago
_SERVERS = [
7 years ago
'c++', 'node', 'csharp', 'csharpcoreclr', 'java', 'go', 'ruby', 'python',
'dart'
7 years ago
]
_TEST_CASES = [
'large_unary', 'empty_unary', 'ping_pong', 'empty_stream',
'client_streaming', 'server_streaming', 'cancel_after_begin',
'cancel_after_first_response', 'timeout_on_sleeping_server',
'custom_metadata', 'status_code_and_message', 'unimplemented_method',
'client_compressed_unary', 'server_compressed_unary',
'client_compressed_streaming', 'server_compressed_streaming',
'unimplemented_service', 'special_status_message'
7 years ago
]
_AUTH_TEST_CASES = [
'compute_engine_creds', 'jwt_token_creds', 'oauth2_auth_token',
'per_rpc_creds'
]
_HTTP2_TEST_CASES = ['tls', 'framing']
7 years ago
_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES = [
'rst_after_header', 'rst_after_data', 'rst_during_data', 'goaway', 'ping',
'max_streams', 'data_frame_padding', 'no_df_padding_sanity_test'
]
7 years ago
_GRPC_CLIENT_TEST_CASES_FOR_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES = {
'data_frame_padding': 'large_unary',
'no_df_padding_sanity_test': 'large_unary'
}
7 years ago
_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES_THAT_USE_GRPC_CLIENTS = _GRPC_CLIENT_TEST_CASES_FOR_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES.keys(
)
7 years ago
_LANGUAGES_WITH_HTTP2_CLIENTS_FOR_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES = [
'java', 'go', 'python', 'c++'
]
_LANGUAGES_FOR_ALTS_TEST_CASES = ['java', 'go', 'c++']
_SERVERS_FOR_ALTS_TEST_CASES = ['java', 'go', 'c++']
_TRANSPORT_SECURITY_OPTIONS = [
'tls', 'alts', 'google_default_credentials', 'insecure'
]
DOCKER_WORKDIR_ROOT = '/var/local/git/grpc'
7 years ago
def docker_run_cmdline(cmdline, image, docker_args=[], cwd=None, environ=None):
7 years ago
"""Wraps given cmdline array to create 'docker run' cmdline from it."""
docker_cmdline = ['docker', 'run', '-i', '--rm=true']
7 years ago
# turn environ into -e docker args
if environ:
for k, v in environ.items():
docker_cmdline += ['-e', '%s=%s' % (k, v)]
7 years ago
# set working directory
workdir = DOCKER_WORKDIR_ROOT
if cwd:
workdir = os.path.join(workdir, cwd)
docker_cmdline += ['-w', workdir]
7 years ago
docker_cmdline += docker_args + [image] + cmdline
return docker_cmdline
def manual_cmdline(docker_cmdline, docker_image):
7 years ago
"""Returns docker cmdline adjusted for manual invocation."""
print_cmdline = []
for item in docker_cmdline:
if item.startswith('--name='):
continue
if item == docker_image:
item = "$docker_image"
item = item.replace('"', '\\"')
# add quotes when necessary
if any(character.isspace() for character in item):
item = "\"%s\"" % item
print_cmdline.append(item)
return ' '.join(print_cmdline)
def write_cmdlog_maybe(cmdlog, filename):
7 years ago
"""Returns docker cmdline adjusted for manual invocation."""
if cmdlog:
with open(filename, 'w') as logfile:
logfile.write('#!/bin/bash\n')
logfile.write('# DO NOT MODIFY\n')
logfile.write(
'# This file is generated by run_interop_tests.py/create_testcases.sh\n'
)
7 years ago
logfile.writelines("%s\n" % line for line in cmdlog)
print('Command log written to file %s' % filename)
def bash_cmdline(cmdline):
7 years ago
"""Creates bash -c cmdline from args list."""
# Use login shell:
# * makes error messages clearer if executables are missing
return ['bash', '-c', ' '.join(cmdline)]
def compute_engine_creds_required(language, test_case):
"""Returns True if given test requires access to compute engine creds."""
language = str(language)
if test_case == 'compute_engine_creds':
return True
if test_case == 'oauth2_auth_token' and language == 'c++':
# C++ oauth2 test uses GCE creds because C++ only supports JWT
return True
return False
def auth_options(language, test_case, service_account_key_file=None):
7 years ago
"""Returns (cmdline, env) tuple with cloud_to_prod_auth test options."""
7 years ago
language = str(language)
cmdargs = []
env = {}
if not service_account_key_file:
# this file path only works inside docker
service_account_key_file = '/root/service_account/GrpcTesting-726eb1347f15.json'
7 years ago
oauth_scope_arg = '--oauth_scope=https://www.googleapis.com/auth/xapi.zoo'
key_file_arg = '--service_account_key_file=%s' % service_account_key_file
7 years ago
default_account_arg = '--default_service_account=830293263384-compute@developer.gserviceaccount.com'
# TODO: When using google_default_credentials outside of cloud-to-prod, the environment variable
# 'GOOGLE_APPLICATION_CREDENTIALS' needs to be set for the test case
# 'jwt_token_creds' to work.
7 years ago
if test_case in ['jwt_token_creds', 'per_rpc_creds', 'oauth2_auth_token']:
if language in [
'csharp', 'csharpcoreclr', 'node', 'php', 'php7', 'python',
'ruby', 'nodepurejs'
7 years ago
]:
env['GOOGLE_APPLICATION_CREDENTIALS'] = service_account_key_file
7 years ago
else:
cmdargs += [key_file_arg]
7 years ago
if test_case in ['per_rpc_creds', 'oauth2_auth_token']:
cmdargs += [oauth_scope_arg]
7 years ago
if test_case == 'oauth2_auth_token' and language == 'c++':
# C++ oauth2 test uses GCE creds and thus needs to know the default account
cmdargs += [default_account_arg]
7 years ago
if test_case == 'compute_engine_creds':
cmdargs += [oauth_scope_arg, default_account_arg]
7 years ago
return (cmdargs, env)
def _job_kill_handler(job):
7 years ago
if job._spec.container_name:
dockerjob.docker_kill(job._spec.container_name)
# When the job times out and we decide to kill it,
# we need to wait a before restarting the job
# to prevent "container name already in use" error.
# TODO(jtattermusch): figure out a cleaner way to to this.
time.sleep(2)
def cloud_to_prod_jobspec(language,
test_case,
server_host_nickname,
server_host,
7 years ago
docker_image=None,
auth=False,
manual_cmd_log=None,
service_account_key_file=None,
transport_security='tls'):
7 years ago
"""Creates jobspec for cloud-to-prod interop test"""
container_name = None
cmdargs = [
'--server_host=%s' % server_host, '--server_port=443',
'--test_case=%s' % test_case
7 years ago
]
if transport_security == 'tls':
transport_security_options = ['--use_tls=true']
elif transport_security == 'google_default_credentials' and str(
language) in ['c++', 'go', 'java', 'javaokhttp']:
transport_security_options = [
'--custom_credentials_type=google_default_credentials'
]
else:
print('Invalid transport security option %s in cloud_to_prod_jobspec.' %
transport_security)
sys.exit(1)
cmdargs = cmdargs + transport_security_options
7 years ago
environ = dict(language.cloud_to_prod_env(), **language.global_env())
if auth:
auth_cmdargs, auth_env = auth_options(language, test_case,
service_account_key_file)
7 years ago
cmdargs += auth_cmdargs
environ.update(auth_env)
cmdline = bash_cmdline(language.client_cmd(cmdargs))
cwd = language.client_cwd
7 years ago
if docker_image:
container_name = dockerjob.random_name(
'interop_client_%s' % language.safename)
7 years ago
cmdline = docker_run_cmdline(
cmdline,
image=docker_image,
cwd=cwd,
environ=environ,
docker_args=['--net=host',
'--name=%s' % container_name])
7 years ago
if manual_cmd_log is not None:
if manual_cmd_log == []:
manual_cmd_log.append(
'echo "Testing ${docker_image:=%s}"' % docker_image)
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log.append(manual_cmdline(cmdline, docker_image))
cwd = None
environ = None
suite_name = 'cloud_to_prod_auth' if auth else 'cloud_to_prod'
test_job = jobset.JobSpec(
cmdline=cmdline,
cwd=cwd,
environ=environ,
shortname='%s:%s:%s:%s:%s' %
(suite_name, language, server_host_nickname, test_case,
transport_security),
7 years ago
timeout_seconds=_TEST_TIMEOUT,
flake_retries=4 if args.allow_flakes else 0,
timeout_retries=2 if args.allow_flakes else 0,
kill_handler=_job_kill_handler)
if docker_image:
test_job.container_name = container_name
return test_job
def cloud_to_cloud_jobspec(language,
test_case,
server_name,
server_host,
server_port,
docker_image=None,
transport_security='tls',
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log=None):
"""Creates jobspec for cloud-to-cloud interop test"""
interop_only_options = [
'--server_host_override=foo.test.google.fr',
'--use_test_ca=true',
]
if transport_security == 'tls':
interop_only_options += ['--use_tls=true']
elif transport_security == 'alts':
interop_only_options += ['--use_tls=false', '--use_alts=true']
elif transport_security == 'insecure':
interop_only_options += ['--use_tls=false']
else:
print('Invalid transport security option %s in cloud_to_cloud_jobspec.'
% transport_security)
sys.exit(1)
7 years ago
client_test_case = test_case
if test_case in _HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES_THAT_USE_GRPC_CLIENTS:
7 years ago
client_test_case = _GRPC_CLIENT_TEST_CASES_FOR_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES[
test_case]
if client_test_case in language.unimplemented_test_cases():
print('asking client %s to run unimplemented test case %s' %
(repr(language), client_test_case))
sys.exit(1)
common_options = [
'--test_case=%s' % client_test_case,
'--server_host=%s' % server_host,
'--server_port=%s' % server_port,
]
7 years ago
if test_case in _HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES:
if test_case in _HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES_THAT_USE_GRPC_CLIENTS:
client_options = interop_only_options + common_options
cmdline = bash_cmdline(language.client_cmd(client_options))
cwd = language.client_cwd
else:
cmdline = bash_cmdline(
language.client_cmd_http2interop(common_options))
cwd = language.http2_cwd
else:
cmdline = bash_cmdline(
language.client_cmd(common_options + interop_only_options))
cwd = language.client_cwd
environ = language.global_env()
if docker_image and language.safename != 'objc':
# we can't run client in docker for objc.
container_name = dockerjob.random_name(
'interop_client_%s' % language.safename)
7 years ago
cmdline = docker_run_cmdline(
cmdline,
image=docker_image,
environ=environ,
cwd=cwd,
docker_args=['--net=host',
'--name=%s' % container_name])
7 years ago
if manual_cmd_log is not None:
if manual_cmd_log == []:
manual_cmd_log.append(
'echo "Testing ${docker_image:=%s}"' % docker_image)
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log.append(manual_cmdline(cmdline, docker_image))
cwd = None
test_job = jobset.JobSpec(
cmdline=cmdline,
cwd=cwd,
environ=environ,
shortname='cloud_to_cloud:%s:%s_server:%s:%s' %
(language, server_name, test_case, transport_security),
7 years ago
timeout_seconds=_TEST_TIMEOUT,
flake_retries=4 if args.allow_flakes else 0,
timeout_retries=2 if args.allow_flakes else 0,
kill_handler=_job_kill_handler)
if docker_image:
test_job.container_name = container_name
return test_job
def server_jobspec(language,
docker_image,
transport_security='tls',
manual_cmd_log=None):
7 years ago
"""Create jobspec for running a server"""
container_name = dockerjob.random_name(
'interop_server_%s' % language.safename)
server_cmd = ['--port=%s' % _DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT]
if transport_security == 'tls':
server_cmd += ['--use_tls=true']
elif transport_security == 'alts':
server_cmd += ['--use_tls=false', '--use_alts=true']
elif transport_security == 'insecure':
server_cmd += ['--use_tls=false']
else:
print('Invalid transport security option %s in server_jobspec.' %
transport_security)
sys.exit(1)
cmdline = bash_cmdline(language.server_cmd(server_cmd))
7 years ago
environ = language.global_env()
docker_args = ['--name=%s' % container_name]
if language.safename == 'http2':
# we are running the http2 interop server. Open next N ports beginning
# with the server port. These ports are used for http2 interop test
# (one test case per port).
docker_args += list(
itertools.chain.from_iterable(
('-p', str(_DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT + i))
for i in range(len(_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES))))
7 years ago
# Enable docker's healthcheck mechanism.
# This runs a Python script inside the container every second. The script
# pings the http2 server to verify it is ready. The 'health-retries' flag
# specifies the number of consecutive failures before docker will report
# the container's status as 'unhealthy'. Prior to the first 'health_retries'
# failures or the first success, the status will be 'starting'. 'docker ps'
# or 'docker inspect' can be used to see the health of the container on the
# command line.
docker_args += [
'--health-cmd=python test/http2_test/http2_server_health_check.py '
'--server_host=%s --server_port=%d' % ('localhost',
_DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT),
7 years ago
'--health-interval=1s',
'--health-retries=5',
'--health-timeout=10s',
]
7 years ago
else:
docker_args += ['-p', str(_DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT)]
docker_cmdline = docker_run_cmdline(
cmdline,
image=docker_image,
cwd=language.server_cwd,
environ=environ,
docker_args=docker_args)
if manual_cmd_log is not None:
if manual_cmd_log == []:
manual_cmd_log.append(
'echo "Testing ${docker_image:=%s}"' % docker_image)
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log.append(manual_cmdline(docker_cmdline, docker_image))
server_job = jobset.JobSpec(
cmdline=docker_cmdline,
environ=environ,
shortname='interop_server_%s' % language,
timeout_seconds=30 * 60)
server_job.container_name = container_name
return server_job
def build_interop_image_jobspec(language, tag=None):
7 years ago
"""Creates jobspec for building interop docker image for a language"""
if not tag:
tag = 'grpc_interop_%s:%s' % (language.safename, uuid.uuid4())
env = {
'INTEROP_IMAGE': tag,
'BASE_NAME': 'grpc_interop_%s' % language.safename
}
if not args.travis:
env['TTY_FLAG'] = '-t'
# This env variable is used to get around the github rate limit
# error when running the PHP `composer install` command
host_file = '%s/.composer/auth.json' % os.environ['HOME']
if language.safename == 'php' and os.path.exists(host_file):
env['BUILD_INTEROP_DOCKER_EXTRA_ARGS'] = \
'-v %s:/root/.composer/auth.json:ro' % host_file
build_job = jobset.JobSpec(
cmdline=['tools/run_tests/dockerize/build_interop_image.sh'],
environ=env,
shortname='build_docker_%s' % (language),
timeout_seconds=30 * 60)
build_job.tag = tag
return build_job
def aggregate_http2_results(stdout):
7 years ago
match = re.search(r'\{"cases[^\]]*\]\}', stdout)
if not match:
return None
results = json.loads(match.group(0))
skipped = 0
passed = 0
failed = 0
failed_cases = []
for case in results['cases']:
if case.get('skipped', False):
skipped += 1
else:
if case.get('passed', False):
passed += 1
else:
failed += 1
failed_cases.append(case.get('name', "NONAME"))
return {
'passed': passed,
'failed': failed,
'skipped': skipped,
'failed_cases': ', '.join(failed_cases),
'percent': 1.0 * passed / (passed + failed)
}
# A dictionary of prod servers to test.
prod_servers = {
'default': 'grpc-test.sandbox.googleapis.com',
'gateway_v4': 'grpc-test4.sandbox.googleapis.com',
}
argp = argparse.ArgumentParser(description='Run interop tests.')
7 years ago
argp.add_argument(
'-l',
'--language',
choices=['all'] + sorted(_LANGUAGES),
nargs='+',
default=['all'],
help='Clients to run. Objc client can be only run on OSX.')
argp.add_argument('-j', '--jobs', default=multiprocessing.cpu_count(), type=int)
7 years ago
argp.add_argument(
'--cloud_to_prod',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help='Run cloud_to_prod tests.')
argp.add_argument(
'--cloud_to_prod_auth',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help='Run cloud_to_prod_auth tests.')
argp.add_argument(
'--prod_servers',
choices=prod_servers.keys(),
default=['default'],
nargs='+',
help=('The servers to run cloud_to_prod and '
'cloud_to_prod_auth tests against.'))
argp.add_argument(
'-s',
'--server',
choices=['all'] + sorted(_SERVERS),
nargs='+',
help='Run cloud_to_cloud servers in a separate docker ' +
'image. Servers can only be started automatically if ' +
'--use_docker option is enabled.',
default=[])
argp.add_argument(
'--override_server',
action='append',
type=lambda kv: kv.split('='),
help=
'Use servername=HOST:PORT to explicitly specify a server. E.g. csharp=localhost:50000',
7 years ago
default=[])
argp.add_argument(
'--service_account_key_file',
type=str,
help=
'Override the default service account key file to use for auth interop tests.',
default=None)
7 years ago
argp.add_argument(
'-t', '--travis', default=False, action='store_const', const=True)
argp.add_argument(
'-v', '--verbose', default=False, action='store_const', const=True)
argp.add_argument(
'--use_docker',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help='Run all the interop tests under docker. That provides ' +
'additional isolation and prevents the need to install ' +
'language specific prerequisites. Only available on Linux.')
argp.add_argument(
'--allow_flakes',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help=
'Allow flaky tests to show as passing (re-runs failed tests up to five times)'
7 years ago
)
argp.add_argument(
'--manual_run',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help='Prepare things for running interop tests manually. ' +
'Preserve docker images after building them and skip '
'actually running the tests. Only print commands to run by ' + 'hand.')
argp.add_argument(
'--http2_interop',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help='Enable HTTP/2 client edge case testing. (Bad client, good server)')
argp.add_argument(
'--http2_server_interop',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help=
'Enable HTTP/2 server edge case testing. (Includes positive and negative tests'
7 years ago
)
argp.add_argument(
'--transport_security',
choices=_TRANSPORT_SECURITY_OPTIONS,
default='tls',
type=str,
nargs='?',
7 years ago
const=True,
help='Which transport security mechanism to use.')
argp.add_argument(
'--skip_compute_engine_creds',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help='Skip auth tests requiring access to compute engine credentials.')
7 years ago
argp.add_argument(
'--internal_ci',
default=False,
action='store_const',
const=True,
help=(
'(Deprecated, has no effect) Put reports into subdirectories to improve '
'presentation of results by Internal CI.'))
7 years ago
argp.add_argument(
'--bq_result_table',
default='',
type=str,
nargs='?',
help='Upload test results to a specified BQ table.')
args = argp.parse_args()
7 years ago
servers = set(
s
for s in itertools.chain.from_iterable(
_SERVERS if x == 'all' else [x] for x in args.server))
# ALTS servers are only available for certain languages.
if args.transport_security == 'alts':
servers = servers.intersection(_SERVERS_FOR_ALTS_TEST_CASES)
if args.use_docker:
7 years ago
if not args.travis:
print('Seen --use_docker flag, will run interop tests under docker.')
print('')
print(
'IMPORTANT: The changes you are testing need to be locally committed'
)
print(
'because only the committed changes in the current branch will be')
print('copied to the docker environment.')
time.sleep(5)
if args.manual_run and not args.use_docker:
7 years ago
print('--manual_run is only supported with --use_docker option enabled.')
sys.exit(1)
if not args.use_docker and servers:
7 years ago
print(
'Running interop servers is only supported with --use_docker option enabled.'
)
sys.exit(1)
# we want to include everything but objc in 'all'
# because objc won't run on non-mac platforms
all_but_objc = set(six.iterkeys(_LANGUAGES)) - set(['objc'])
languages = set(_LANGUAGES[l]
for l in itertools.chain.from_iterable(
all_but_objc if x == 'all' else [x] for x in args.language))
# ALTS interop clients are only available for certain languages.
if args.transport_security == 'alts':
alts_languages = set(_LANGUAGES[l] for l in _LANGUAGES_FOR_ALTS_TEST_CASES)
languages = languages.intersection(alts_languages)
languages_http2_clients_for_http2_server_interop = set()
if args.http2_server_interop:
7 years ago
languages_http2_clients_for_http2_server_interop = set(
_LANGUAGES[l]
for l in _LANGUAGES_WITH_HTTP2_CLIENTS_FOR_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES
if 'all' in args.language or l in args.language)
http2Interop = Http2Client() if args.http2_interop else None
http2InteropServer = Http2Server() if args.http2_server_interop else None
7 years ago
docker_images = {}
if args.use_docker:
7 years ago
# languages for which to build docker images
languages_to_build = set(
_LANGUAGES[k]
for k in set([str(l) for l in languages] + [s for s in servers]))
languages_to_build = languages_to_build | languages_http2_clients_for_http2_server_interop
7 years ago
if args.http2_interop:
languages_to_build.add(http2Interop)
if args.http2_server_interop:
languages_to_build.add(http2InteropServer)
build_jobs = []
for l in languages_to_build:
if str(l) == 'objc':
# we don't need to build a docker image for objc
continue
job = build_interop_image_jobspec(l)
docker_images[str(l)] = job.tag
build_jobs.append(job)
if build_jobs:
jobset.message(
'START', 'Building interop docker images.', do_newline=True)
if args.verbose:
print('Jobs to run: \n%s\n' % '\n'.join(str(j) for j in build_jobs))
num_failures, build_resultset = jobset.run(
7 years ago
build_jobs, newline_on_success=True, maxjobs=args.jobs)
report_utils.render_junit_xml_report(build_resultset,
_DOCKER_BUILD_XML_REPORT)
7 years ago
if num_failures == 0:
jobset.message(
'SUCCESS',
'All docker images built successfully.',
do_newline=True)
else:
jobset.message(
'FAILED',
'Failed to build interop docker images.',
do_newline=True)
for image in six.itervalues(docker_images):
dockerjob.remove_image(image, skip_nonexistent=True)
sys.exit(1)
server_manual_cmd_log = [] if args.manual_run else None
client_manual_cmd_log = [] if args.manual_run else None
# Start interop servers.
server_jobs = {}
server_addresses = {}
try:
7 years ago
for s in servers:
lang = str(s)
spec = server_jobspec(
_LANGUAGES[lang],
docker_images.get(lang),
args.transport_security,
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log=server_manual_cmd_log)
if not args.manual_run:
7 years ago
job = dockerjob.DockerJob(spec)
server_jobs[lang] = job
server_addresses[lang] = ('localhost',
job.mapped_port(_DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT))
else:
# don't run the server, set server port to a placeholder value
server_addresses[lang] = ('localhost', '${SERVER_PORT}')
http2_server_job = None
if args.http2_server_interop:
# launch a HTTP2 server emulator that creates edge cases
lang = str(http2InteropServer)
spec = server_jobspec(
http2InteropServer,
docker_images.get(lang),
manual_cmd_log=server_manual_cmd_log)
if not args.manual_run:
http2_server_job = dockerjob.DockerJob(spec)
server_jobs[lang] = http2_server_job
else:
# don't run the server, set server port to a placeholder value
server_addresses[lang] = ('localhost', '${SERVER_PORT}')
jobs = []
if args.cloud_to_prod:
if args.transport_security not in ['tls', 'google_default_credentials']:
print(
'TLS or google default credential is always enabled for cloud_to_prod scenarios.'
)
for server_host_nickname in args.prod_servers:
7 years ago
for language in languages:
for test_case in _TEST_CASES:
if not test_case in language.unimplemented_test_cases():
if not test_case in _SKIP_ADVANCED + _SKIP_COMPRESSION + _SKIP_SPECIAL_STATUS_MESSAGE:
tls_test_job = cloud_to_prod_jobspec(
7 years ago
language,
test_case,
server_host_nickname,
prod_servers[server_host_nickname],
7 years ago
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(language)),
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log,
service_account_key_file=args.
service_account_key_file,
transport_security='tls')
jobs.append(tls_test_job)
if str(language) in [
'c++', 'go', 'java', 'javaokhttp'
]:
google_default_creds_test_job = cloud_to_prod_jobspec(
language,
test_case,
server_host_nickname,
prod_servers[server_host_nickname],
docker_image=docker_images.get(
str(language)),
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log,
service_account_key_file=args.
service_account_key_file,
transport_security=
'google_default_credentials')
jobs.append(google_default_creds_test_job)
7 years ago
if args.http2_interop:
for test_case in _HTTP2_TEST_CASES:
test_job = cloud_to_prod_jobspec(
http2Interop,
test_case,
server_host_nickname,
prod_servers[server_host_nickname],
7 years ago
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(http2Interop)),
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log,
service_account_key_file=args.service_account_key_file,
transport_security=args.transport_security)
7 years ago
jobs.append(test_job)
if args.cloud_to_prod_auth:
if args.transport_security not in ['tls', 'google_default_credentials']:
print(
'TLS or google default credential is always enabled for cloud_to_prod scenarios.'
)
for server_host_nickname in args.prod_servers:
7 years ago
for language in languages:
for test_case in _AUTH_TEST_CASES:
if (not args.skip_compute_engine_creds or
not compute_engine_creds_required(
language, test_case)):
if not test_case in language.unimplemented_test_cases():
tls_test_job = cloud_to_prod_jobspec(
language,
test_case,
server_host_nickname,
prod_servers[server_host_nickname],
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(language)),
auth=True,
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log,
service_account_key_file=args.
service_account_key_file,
transport_security='tls')
jobs.append(tls_test_job)
if str(language) in [
'go'
]: # Add more languages to the list to turn on tests.
google_default_creds_test_job = cloud_to_prod_jobspec(
language,
test_case,
server_host_nickname,
prod_servers[server_host_nickname],
docker_image=docker_images.get(
str(language)),
auth=True,
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log,
service_account_key_file=args.
service_account_key_file,
transport_security=
'google_default_credentials')
jobs.append(google_default_creds_test_job)
7 years ago
for server in args.override_server:
server_name = server[0]
(server_host, server_port) = server[1].split(':')
server_addresses[server_name] = (server_host, server_port)
for server_name, server_address in server_addresses.items():
(server_host, server_port) = server_address
server_language = _LANGUAGES.get(server_name, None)
skip_server = [] # test cases unimplemented by server
if server_language:
skip_server = server_language.unimplemented_test_cases_server()
for language in languages:
for test_case in _TEST_CASES:
if not test_case in language.unimplemented_test_cases():
if not test_case in skip_server:
test_job = cloud_to_cloud_jobspec(
language,
test_case,
server_name,
server_host,
server_port,
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(language)),
transport_security=args.transport_security,
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log)
jobs.append(test_job)
if args.http2_interop:
for test_case in _HTTP2_TEST_CASES:
if server_name == "go":
# TODO(carl-mastrangelo): Reenable after https://github.com/grpc/grpc-go/issues/434
continue
test_job = cloud_to_cloud_jobspec(
http2Interop,
test_case,
server_name,
server_host,
server_port,
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(http2Interop)),
transport_security=args.transport_security,
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log)
jobs.append(test_job)
if args.http2_server_interop:
if not args.manual_run:
http2_server_job.wait_for_healthy(timeout_seconds=600)
for language in languages_http2_clients_for_http2_server_interop:
for test_case in set(_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES) - set(
_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES_THAT_USE_GRPC_CLIENTS):
offset = sorted(_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES).index(test_case)
server_port = _DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT + offset
if not args.manual_run:
server_port = http2_server_job.mapped_port(server_port)
test_job = cloud_to_cloud_jobspec(
language,
test_case,
str(http2InteropServer),
'localhost',
server_port,
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(language)),
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log)
jobs.append(test_job)
for language in languages:
# HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES_THAT_USE_GRPC_CLIENTS is a subset of
# HTTP_SERVER_TEST_CASES, in which clients use their gRPC interop clients rather
# than specialized http2 clients, reusing existing test implementations.
# For example, in the "data_frame_padding" test, use language's gRPC
# interop clients and make them think that theyre running "large_unary"
# test case. This avoids implementing a new test case in each language.
for test_case in _HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES_THAT_USE_GRPC_CLIENTS:
if test_case not in language.unimplemented_test_cases():
offset = sorted(_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES).index(test_case)
server_port = _DEFAULT_SERVER_PORT + offset
if not args.manual_run:
server_port = http2_server_job.mapped_port(server_port)
if args.transport_security != 'insecure':
print(
('Creating grpc client to http2 server test case '
'with insecure connection, even though '
'args.transport_security is not insecure. Http2 '
'test server only supports insecure connections.'))
7 years ago
test_job = cloud_to_cloud_jobspec(
language,
test_case,
str(http2InteropServer),
'localhost',
server_port,
docker_image=docker_images.get(str(language)),
transport_security='insecure',
7 years ago
manual_cmd_log=client_manual_cmd_log)
jobs.append(test_job)
if not jobs:
print('No jobs to run.')
for image in six.itervalues(docker_images):
dockerjob.remove_image(image, skip_nonexistent=True)
sys.exit(1)
if args.manual_run:
print('All tests will skipped --manual_run option is active.')
7 years ago
if args.verbose:
print('Jobs to run: \n%s\n' % '\n'.join(str(job) for job in jobs))
num_failures, resultset = jobset.run(
jobs,
newline_on_success=True,
maxjobs=args.jobs,
skip_jobs=args.manual_run)
if args.bq_result_table and resultset:
upload_interop_results_to_bq(resultset, args.bq_result_table)
7 years ago
if num_failures:
jobset.message('FAILED', 'Some tests failed', do_newline=True)
else:
jobset.message('SUCCESS', 'All tests passed', do_newline=True)
7 years ago
write_cmdlog_maybe(server_manual_cmd_log, 'interop_server_cmds.sh')
write_cmdlog_maybe(client_manual_cmd_log, 'interop_client_cmds.sh')
report_utils.render_junit_xml_report(resultset, _TESTS_XML_REPORT)
7 years ago
for name, job in resultset.items():
if "http2" in name:
job[0].http2results = aggregate_http2_results(job[0].message)
7 years ago
http2_server_test_cases = (_HTTP2_SERVER_TEST_CASES
if args.http2_server_interop else [])
7 years ago
if num_failures:
sys.exit(1)
else:
sys.exit(0)
finally:
7 years ago
# Check if servers are still running.
for server, job in server_jobs.items():
if not job.is_running():
print('Server "%s" has exited prematurely.' % server)
7 years ago
dockerjob.finish_jobs([j for j in six.itervalues(server_jobs)])
7 years ago
for image in six.itervalues(docker_images):
if not args.manual_run:
print('Removing docker image %s' % image)
dockerjob.remove_image(image)
else:
print('Preserving docker image: %s' % image)