To trigger this bug, use `paletteuse=dither=bayer:bayer_scale=0`; you will see
that adjacent pixel lines will use the same dither pattern, instead of being
shifted from each other by 32 units (0x20).
One way to demostrate the bug is:
$ convert -size 64x256 gradient:black-white -rotate 270 grad.png
$ echo 'P2 2 1 255 0 255' > bw.pnm
$ ffmpeg -i grad.png -filter_complex 'movie=bw.pnm,scale=256x1[bw]; [0:v][bw]paletteuse=dither=bayer:bayer_scale=0' gradbw.png
Previously: https://www.rm.cloudns.org/img/uploaded/0bd152c11b9cd99e5945115534b1bdde.png
Now: https://www.rm.cloudns.org/img/uploaded/89caaa5e36c38bc2c01755b30811f969.png
This was caused by passing inconsistent color vs (a,r,g,b) parameters to
color_get(), and NBITS being 5 meaning actually hitting the same cache node
does happen in this case, but ONLY if bayer_scale is zero.
The fix is passing the correct color value to color_get().
Also added a previous-failing FATE test; image comparison of the first frame:
Previously: https://www.rm.cloudns.org/img/uploaded/d0ff9db8d8a7d8a3b8b88bbe92bf5fed.png
Now: https://www.rm.cloudns.org/img/uploaded/a72389707e719b5cd1c58916a9e79ca8.png
(on this less synthetic test image, the bug basically causes noise from cache
hits vs misses)
Tested: FATE passes, which exercises this filter but at the default bayer_scale.
Reviewed-by: Paul B Mahol <onemda@gmail.com>
Rudolf Polzer
dcc9454ab9
